Image 01

Posts Tagged ‘health care’

Hi Risk, Low Risk, It Doesn’t Matter

Friday, August 20th, 2010

Unin­su­red Slow To Enroll In New High-Risk Pools Don’t tell me they couldn’t have pre­dic­ted this. Par­ti­cu­larly since it cost more than some of these peo­ple take home in a week. Loo­king for­ward, with no sig­ni­fi­cant regu­la­tion of the cost of the plans, or the cost of the care, it isn’t likely to change. The price is not right for most.

It’s not only high risk pools. The inc­rease in rates ( exam­ple Mary­land where the rates inc­rea­sed 40 per­cent last year for many plans, after having inc­rea­sed almost twenty per­cent the year before), has cau­sed emplo­yers who have plans to go to a high deduc­ti­ble plan ( In some cases well over 4 grand a year for a family), or drop their plans alto­gether. That 4 grand comes easier for some than for others. It often pre­vents those who can’t afford the deduc­ti­bles from seeing a doc­tor for things that maybe they should be seeing a doc­tor for. So, here we are right back where we star­ted, with those at the middle part of the spec­trum get­ting stuck. They have insu­rance that cost what is to them a for­tune, but it is worth­less except in the case of a hos­pi­ta­li­za­tion or other catas­trophic illness.

Then there are silly poli­ti­cal moves. In my state a busi­ness gets a tax break or cre­dit of 7 or 8 grand for busi­nes­ses who offer insu­rance for the first time, but no break for busi­ness who have con­sis­tently offe­red it, des­pite the fact the astro­no­mi­cal inc­rease in their rates over the last two years. As a result there are as many busi­nes­ses drop­ping their group plans as there are ini­tia­ting a plan. Talk about get­ting get­ting nowhere fast.

The mar­ket based regu­la­tory model doesn’t work for health insu­rance, at least not to the bene­fit of those purcha­sing it. In a free mar­ket there is sup­po­sed to be satis­fac­tion on both sides. Tit for tat. You pay “this” and get “that”. What you get should be worth what you pay for, or at least make you happy. Both sides are sup­po­sed to be con­tent here. With health insu­rance — espe­cially with these high deduc­ti­ble plans that are currently the insu­rance com­pa­nies pro­fit nir­vana — you pay “this”, but don’t get anything until you’ve paid another (huge deduc­ti­ble), “that”. “That” being the bit you can’t afford. Con­se­quently, you don’t use the insu­rance you pay for. You skip going to the doc­tor for that recu­rring sore throat that could be can­cer, or that strange rash — a symp­tom of leu­ke­mia. You wait too long because you just can’t afford the deduc­ti­ble this week, this month, this year. The insu­rance com­pa­nies smile.
Progress

A com­ments off I shouldn’t read NPR during lunch presentation.